Friday, December 23, 2011

The debate...

There are times in every man's life when he must make important choices. Choices that will affect him and the ones that he loves. With the impending arrival of my first kid, I find myself at just such a crossroads, staring into the abyss of indecision.

A little background information. I'm a transplanted Montrealer living in New York City. My only sports allegiance is to the bleu, blanc et rouge of the Montreal Canadiens. Though my childhood fandom wasn't quite as intense as this guy's, it's safe to say that from a young age, there was only one team that mattered. We were always a one sport family, and though there were a few trips to the Big O, I knew the only stadium that mattered was located at Atwater and St. Catherine.

It was easy to be a fan in Montreal, and almost everyone was a Habs fan. I'm more than happy to pass my love of les Glorieux on to my son, as my father and grandfathers passed theirs on to me. That said, in New York, there are 8 million people and we're inundated with teams to support. They've got the "world's greatest arena" and the "House that Ruth Built." It's the city of Mantle and Dimaggio. Seaver and Mays. Bradley and Ewing (and Starks). We're literally spoiled with a luxury of teams. I can get behind the Knicks, and the Red Bulls can count on my support. As for baseball, I have no problem building my son's street cred with Expos gear, and eventually he can join the dedicated few who mourn the passing of nos amours. As you can imagine, appreciation of the Rangers, Devils, or Islanders is out of the question.

Football is another story. I've watched football. I enjoy football. I used to read books about Joe Montana and eat Bo Jackson Pro Stars cereal. However, I have no NFL allegiances. As much as I admire my hometown Alouettes (and Calvillo still doesn't get the respect he deserves), I can't in good conscience send my kid to school in this jersey.

Football is religion in this country, and I can't deprive my unborn child of the benefits of fandom. The feeling of an entire city celebrating a win and mourning a loss. The spontaneous outpouring of goodwill after a championship is brought home. It wouldn't be fair. It wouldn't be right. The question is, a fan of which team? Big Blue or Gang Green? Broadway Joe or Phil Simms? The Sanchize or the Luke Wilson of the NFL? They've each had success and scandal (see here for my favorite, and here for the most disturbing). They play in the same stadium, so geography can't decide this dilemma.

Bloomberg's already made his choice. Help me make mine.

3 comments:

  1. I vote Giants. Otherwise Samson won't be able to be friends with your future child. Debate over.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the blog. No question, gotta go with the G-men. Jets fans are doomed to eternal misery and second-class status. You would not adopt the mets unless you want to forever long for success and pride so you cannot adopt the jets. It's an easy decision. The giants have LT, Simms, manning, bavaro, parcells, and stories tradition beyond our lifetimes. The jets have a guy who tried to make out with suzy kolber. Welcome to new York. Go rangers!

    ReplyDelete
  3. ‎(tried to post comment but don't think it worked so I'll put it here). Great blog. The house Ruth built is gone. Steinbrenner built this one. Also, as a Pats fan, I've learned to despise BOTH of these teams. I think it would be best for you to forget both of these awful franchises and get your season tickets now for the New York Sharks (www.wfafootball.com). You and your kid will thank me later.

    ReplyDelete